"Masterful
storytelling about gun ownership gone beserk. Compulsive, entertaining and
sickening, Moore comes out with both barrels blazing! (pun intended)"
Using the tragedy of
the shootings at Columbine High School in the United States as a stepping
point, Michael Moore illustrates the American infatuation with weapons and the
gun culture. It is concise, witty and ultimately sad to the point of almost
tears.
Interviews abound on
this DVD, from the normal man on the street, through to the singer Marilyn
Manson, whom some blame for the shootings at Columbine because of the
inflammatory nature of his lyrics. Comparisons are done on the level of gun
related homicides in the USA and around the world and the comparison is
shocking, with the USA outnumbering every other country featured by many many
thousand.
Why do Americans like
to kill each other so much? Despite his best efforts, Moore can only come back
to the same reason; the nation is kept in a state of fear where it is easier
to react with force than reason. Add to that paranoia the fact that you can go
to a bank, open an account and they'll hand you a weapon your choice. Then you
can go to the local K Mart and buy bullets over the counter with no ID
required whatsoever.
An interesting
counterpoint to this tale is when Michael goes to Canada, a nation where gun
ownership is just as high pro rata as the USA, however the homicide rate is
virtually non existent by comparison. It's also great listening to the reasons
why Canadians think that Americans are so prone to killing each other.
Cut to extremely
chilling video footage inside Columbine High School during the actual
shootings and we see the kids running in terror and panic as the two killers
casually walk among them, dispensing death and injury at their whim. Over the
top of this is audio of emergency calls being made during the actual attack
that bring home the sense of loss that these poor people had to suffer.
A highlight for me is
when two of the kids horribly injured by the Columbine shootings accompany
Moore to K Mart headquarters as the shooters bought their bullets from a K
Mart store. The irony is that they intended on getting a refund for those
rounds! What actually occurs is something far greater and makes it worth the
watch for that segment alone.
Moore manages to corner
NRA spokesman and esteemed actor Charlton Heston about why he thought it was a
good reason to attend gun rallies in Columbine shortly after the tragedy that
happened there. What follows is amazing as Heston, rather than being the
elegant man that I'd always thought him to be, starts on about the homicide
problem being connected to mixed races in America.
This feature is two
hours of pure entertainment that you have you riveted to the screen. If you
like your humour to be clever, poignant and in your face, then this is the one
for you. In fact this movie should be compulsory viewing in high schools and
there are a number of lesson guides that can be used that are available both
on the disc and www.michaelmoore.com
Bowling for Columbine
scores a ten for it's subject matter and the way that Moore handles it with
integrity and passion. It may not be the perfect documentary, however in a way
it is if only for the simple fact that it is without doubt guaranteed to make
you think about what you can do to make a difference. What you do next about
it, is up to you. For some ideas, look around on the internet for lobby groups
or even visit Moore's site (listed above).
Highest recommendation!
The disc is shown in
16:9 widescreen and it must be remembered that this is not a Hollywood
blockbuster, far from it. Video ranges from clear to grainy when Moore is
actually taping and then accesses archive footage. Everything works perfectly
however and there is absolutely nothing to complain about in terms of visual
quality.
I reviewed this film
using a 5.1 setup and whilst it's a documentary, it still uses the full
surround nicely, although a bit spare on the subwoofer. For the most part
during interviews and dialogue, we mainly hear audio through the centre
speaker and nothing else is used except for when needed. I guess the easiest
way to put it is that it's not used for the sake of having a full surround
mix.
There are two discs in this set and most of the extras are on the second disc.
There are a whole swarm of extras on this set and getting through them all is
nothing short of exhausting and surprisingly enough, there were a few areas
that I was disappointed. For example, Mike doesn't do an audio commentary on
the movie, he gets some of his workers to. Despite the fact that these folks
are the lowest on the payroll, such as interns, assistants and even the
receptionist, they do come out with some funny stuff, although you can't
forget the whole time that these people really are nobodies and you'd rather
hear Mike talking, even if he was in company with these kids.
After that we get to see what happened when Moore won the Oscar and started
talking about George Bush and the war in Iraq. The Academy wouldn't let him
use the footage of his speech so he gives us a rundown on what he said and why
he said it. It's interesting enough even though it's only Mike sitting on his
outdoor setting with the Oscar. By this stage though, we've identified enough
with Moore that it will captivate you.
Possibly the thing that annoys me the most is that Moore only gives an audio
intro to the DVD and you only see a picture of his face and hear the voice. He
believes that the movie does the talking for him and this is the reason why he
doesn't contribute to the commentary.
We do get to see however Michael's return to the community of Columbine after
the shooting and the release of the movie and excerpts of the speech that he
gave there. It's good viewing although heavily edited for time.
Add to that a swag of interviews and some music videos and you have a pretty
comprehensive list of extras on this DVD, all of which are worth making your
way through. Just be prepared to set aside a number of hours to get through
them all. It's a great list of extras.
Bowling for
Columbine Features |
-
Michael Moore's Audio Introduction to DVD
-
Commentary by Michael Moore's Production Assistants,
Interns & Receptionist
-
Michael Moore on his Oscar win
-
Featurette on Michael Moore's Return to Denver/Littleton
-
Interview with Michael Moore and Clinton Press Secretary
Joe Lockhart
-
Michael Moore on the Charlie Rose Show
-
Q&A at UK Press Conference
-
Film Festival Scrapbook
-
Photo Gallery
-
Marilyn Manson's Fight Song Video
-
Teacher's Guide
-
Mike's Action Guide (Web Link)
|
|