I can see what
Inkheart was aiming for: a warming kid’s movie about the magic of
books. It just didn’t work though – at all. The idea is fine, as
proven by the much-loved The Neverending Story, but when you team it
up with odious acting and badly paced story telling it falls flat –
very flat.
Inkheart introduces
us to Mo Folchart (Brendan Fraser), a “silver tongue”, a person
capable of reading the characters and events out of books and into
the real-world. One evening as he reads to his daughter he
accidentally reads a handful of villains out of his fantasy story
into his reading room and reads his wife into the book. The bad guys
set up a base in the real world and decide they wish to stay and
have no intention of being read back in. They go about collecting
and destroying all copies of the book they came from – Inkheart.
Meanwhile Mo spends the next 10 years raising his daughter Meggie
(Eliza Hope Bennet) alone as he tries to find Inkheart and rescue
his wife.
Problem number one
for Inkheart is lead actor Brendon Fraser. The protagonist is
supposed to be a “silver tongue”, able to bring the stories
literally to life through their prestigious narration, however
Brendon Fraser just doesn’t have the ability to pull this off – not
even close. I don’t mind Brendan Fraser, per se, but I know where
his acting abilities extend to and he should stick with movies that
don’t ask so much of him. Brendan: Mummies, good. Talking, bad.
Problem number two
is the disjointed pacing. I suppose I could ask “what pacing?” Even
the climax was incredibly lack-luster, characters and plot
developments dropped in and out without engaging the audience to
care, and there didn’t seem to be any real direction. The characters
travelled here and there, but no-where was particularly interesting
and all they ended up doing was retracing back the way they came
anyway.
There were plot
holes you could drive a truck through (side-ways) but since it was
pitched in the style of a fairy tale, I suppose that can be
forgiven. Usually, however, these sorts of holes are put there for
dramatic purpose but they seemed to just remove any sense of danger
and excitement. Oh well.
The list of problems
goes on though: None of the characters are particularly loveable –
the rogue isn’t roguish enough, the hero not heroic, the love
interest is boring, and the bad guy not very villainous. Is there
anything to recommend about Inkheart?
Well, not really,
actually. It obviously cost quite a bit to make – the special
effects are good quality computer animation and the idea is
laudable, but beyond that there’s no humour, no winks for the
adults, no fun for the kids.