I've watched this DVD twice now, trying to figure out exactly what
to say in this review, and I'm still not completely clear on it. I
guess I'll just have to muddle through, so bear with me!
It has to be said up-front that this is NOT a cartoon for the
kiddies. It hints at sex, and depicts Violence, Drug Use, and
homosexuality. It definitely contains Adult Themes and is NOT
suitable for children. The storyline itself is loosely based on The
Count Of Monte Cristo by Dumas, a plot that's always held problems
of characterization for me. Thankfully, this adaptation to a
science-fiction setting has evaded those issues by showing the story
through the eyes of Albert, a young nobleman seduced into the
Count's dark perspectives on the world. In terms of science fiction,
this is only C-grade; the first two episodes, or "Acts", are set in
a city on the Lunar Surface, but there is no reduced gravity, a
mistake so elementary that even a high school student would
recognise it. But the "science fiction" elements of the story are so
negligible that this is of little importance to the overall review;
except for the occasional moment when you are intentionally reminded
of it, it's easy to forget them and enjoy the show for what's on
screen.
And what's on screen is unique, visually stunning, and yet
distracting at the same time. This series was the first to combine
Photoshop rendering with classical animation technique and the
results are frequently breathtaking. Hair, backgrounds, fireworks,
and sumptuous costuming all take advantage of what was then a new
tool in the animation armory. The problem is that these images don't
move with the animation - it's like a moving cut-out on top of a
textured background. The results are unbelievably beautiful when
characters are standing still and visually confusing when they
aren't; you have to really concentrate in order to process what is
occurring onscreen. Thank goodness the DVD has been dubbed into
English, I don't think I would have been able to cope with the added
distraction of subtitles.
This same mixture of lavishness and distraction is common throughout
the DVD, extending even to the main menu, which is incredibly classy
- until the clouds begin wafting across the screen IN FRONT of the
menu options. It is present in some of the featured extras as well,
for example in an interview with the director the English subtitles
are presented on top of Japanese text, again making the watching
experience harder than it should have been. Speaking of the extras,
while there were some welcome items, such as the inclusion of the
opening and closing animated sequences without titles intruding onto
the images, I somehow was left with the feeling that they were a
little shallow. Perhaps this impression was the result of brevity -
they simply don't last very long.
The most notable comment to make about the DVD sound concern the
songs which play with the opening sequence and end credits, which
are performed in English by a Frenchman, a member of the Stranglers,
probably best known to the mainstream for their 80s hit, "Golden
Brown". Beyond that, it's not exceptionally noteworthy in any
respect. The pictures are presented in standard television format,
not widescreen.
This DVD is the first in a series, ultimately to contain 24 episodes
or acts. The plots of individual episodes on this disc are largely
stand-alone affairs that serve largely to introduce the characters,
though there is ongoing development of a larger plot that will
obviously come to dominate later DVDs. Because of its uniqueness and
sheer visual appeal, there is a place for this series on any anime
fan's bookshelf, and it might well hold greater appeal to the wider
audience as a result; but because it is so unlike most anime, it
would serve poorly as a means of attracting new fans to the medium;
personally, I would still use "Spirited Away" for that purpose, and
THEN hit them with this show as a means of showing the diversity
within the anime genre, followed perhaps by the first episodes of
"Love Hina".